...
Number | Current Text | Proposed Text / Query / Suggestion | Proposer | +1 (add your name here if you agree with the proposal) | Action |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | CILogon has become a critical service for existing collaborations as well as a foundation for broader collaboration, but there is currently no sustainability model. | CILogon has become a critical service for existing collaborations as well as a foundation for broader collaboration, but its current subscription-based sustainability model could benefit from more stable, long-term support. | James Basney (illinois.edu) | The text will be modified as suggested. | |
2 | (p36, sB.11, para #2) The number of participating national identity federations (IDFs) has grown from a handful to 18 in mid 2017, enabling user’s from 1577 organisations to use single sign-on to login to CLARIN services. | The number of participating national identity federations (IDFs) has grown from a handful to 18 in mid 2017, enabling users from 1577 organisations to use single sign-on to login to CLARIN services. | This was in the original FIM4Rv2 paper ("Federated Identity Management for Research Collaborations"), which is already final. | ||
3 | (Gap3 - page 10 IdP of last resort) Researchers from institutions that have not federated their IAM systems are not well served. An IdP of Last Resort that releases R&S attributes and can be used internationally is needed. | Researchers from institutions that have not federated their IAM systems are not well served. An IdP or perhaps a set of regional IdPs (hosted in Research Computing facilities) of Last Resort that releases R&S attributes and can be used internationally is needed. | Warren Curry (ufl.edu) | The text will be modified as suggested. | |
4 | Recommendations related to IdPs as a Service and IdPs of Last Resort. | Be more explicit about which of these is indicated, and how they support research activities. | Oct-18-2018 Open CACTI meeting at TechEx in Orlando | The recommendations related to IdPaaS and IdPoLR will be made more explicit. | |
5 | OIDC | There should be more explicit recommendations regarding use cases that are not handled well with SAML | Oct-18-2018 Open CACTI meeting at TechEx in Orlando | The recommendation has been modified to be more explicit. | |
6 | Timeline | Consider adding a timeline for recommended actions. | Oct-18-2018 Open CACTI meeting at TechEx in Orlando | The decision was not to provide a timeline but to emphasize the need for a roadmap as a next step. | |
7 | The paper's focus on recommendations for InCommon | Consider adding recommendations for the other "strata" in the FIM4Rv2 report (e.g., identity providers, research service providers, software developers). | Oct-18-2018 Open CACTI meeting at TechEx in Orlando | The decision was not to expand the scope of the recommendations, but there is already text highlighting Internet2's unique role to foster action by other "strata." | |
8 | Security | Consider more explicit recommendations for SIRTFI, proactive security assessments, etc. | Oct-18-2018 Open CACTI meeting at TechEx in Orlando | Text has been added to specify compliance with SIRTFI, but SIRTFI-specific recommendations were considered out of scope. | |
9 | Outreach | Consider help for campuses to bridge the gap between researchers and their IAM staff. Also explore ways to reach out to researchers directly. | Oct-18-2018 Open CACTI meeting at TechEx in Orlando | Text has been added to recommend information exchange and partnerships between these communities. | |
10 | Improve clarity of collaboration as a service pivoting on adopters (both sites and projects) understanding the tools, readiness and/or maturity of campus IAM solutions to allow ease of use such that adoption barriers are minimal. | Nov 9 Author's meeting | The text has been edited for clarity. | ||
11 | For each of the authors listed, please provide the ORCID ID where possible. Nicholas Roy: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6515-4316 | Emily Eisbruch | ORCIDs have been added to the list of authors. |
See Also