DRAFT External Identities Work Group Meeting - 2015-01-15

Agenda

• Evaluation Criteria status: Evaluating External Identity Providers
• Review process for “Evaluation Criteria” (if needed)
• Final report draft outline: Outline for Final Report
• Process for creating final report

Notes

• Evaluation Criteria status: https://spaces.at.internet2.edu/display/EXTID/Criteria+for+Evaluating+External+Identity+Providers
  • Many people pleasantly surprised by so many providers having MFA.
  • There's a difference between @gmail.com IDs and Google Apps IDs.
  • What do we care about wrt/ reassignment?  The asserted identifier, although we'd want to know about other things that might be reassigned (login name, email, ...)
  • Facebook will accept a Google login to reset the FB password, but will not accept it to login initially. 
•  Final report draft outline: https://spaces.at.internet2.edu/display/EXTID/Outline+for+Final+Report
  
  • People generally seem happy.  Some comments were edited into the document, and others may add more comments.
• Process for creating final report
  
  • Want contributions in February to get final report out in March.
    
    • John Breen volunteered
    • Mary volunteered as proof reader
    • Eric Goodman
    • David Walker

Action Items

• Eric, John, and David will start work on the final report.